Appraisal & umpire services · All 14 Vermont counties
Vermont Insurance AppraiserIndependent claim valuation (844) 537-1427
Field guide · 6 min read · August 19, 2026

Choosing an Appraiser and an Umpire in a Small State

Vermont is small, and everyone in the claims world seems to know each other. What to ask before you name an appraiser or agree on an umpire.

Vermont is a small state. Contractors, adjusters and appraisers often cross paths again and again. That familiarity can help a panel work smoothly, but it also makes it important to ask the right questions before you name an appraiser or agree on an umpire.

What to look for in an appraiser

  • Estimating skill. Can they build a complete line-item estimate on their own, not just mark up yours?
  • Relevant experience. Roofs, water, fire, historic homes, commercial buildings, farm structures. Ask what they have handled.
  • Impartiality. Many policies require a competent and impartial or disinterested appraiser. Ask about prior relationships with the carrier, the other appraiser and your contractor.
  • Clear fees. Get the fee arrangement in writing before work starts.
  • Honesty about fit. A good appraiser will tell you if your claim needs a lawyer or a supplement instead.

What to look for in an umpire

The umpire should be neutral, experienced in construction costs and willing to disclose any connections to either side. Many umpires are experienced appraisers, contractors, engineers or retired judges. Ask both appraisers to share candidates’ backgrounds and fee quotes.

Questions to ask

  1. Have you worked with or against this carrier or appraiser before? How often?
  2. Have you ever been challenged as not impartial?
  3. How do you charge, and what is included?
  4. Will you inspect in person?
  5. How long do your appraisals usually take?

If the appraisers cannot agree on an umpire

Most policies let either side ask a court in the county where the property is located to appoint one. That adds time and cost, so it is usually a last resort.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Your policy’s wording controls.

Keep reading

Is the carrier’s number short of the repair?

Send us the estimate. We will read it line by line and tell you what we see.

Call nowFree review