Appraisal & umpire services · All 14 Vermont counties
Vermont Insurance AppraiserIndependent claim valuation (844) 537-1427
Free calculator · runs in your browser

Claim Gap & Fee Estimator: Will Appraisal Pay for Itself?

Enter the carrier’s estimate and yours, pick a fee arrangement and see a low, middle and strong outcome side by side. Example figures are illustrative.

Claim gap & fee estimatorRuns in your browser
Replacement cost total before depreciation and deductible.
Your contractor’s or independent estimate.
55%
0% means the carrier’s number holds; 100% means your full number is awarded.
Estimated net increase to you$0
Carrier’s numberYour net gainAppraisal costs
Amount in dispute$0
Gap as % of carrier estimate—
Projected award (RCV)$0
Your appraisal costs$0

Three outcomes side by side

Lands atAwardNet to you

For planning only. Results depend on what you enter and on your policy, and are not a quote, an appraisal or legal advice. Nothing you type is stored or sent.

How to read the three outcomes

Appraisal awards rarely match either side’s opening number. The estimator shows what happens if the award lands at 30%, 60% and 90% of the gap, using your fee arrangement each time. If appraisal only makes sense in the strong column, the case may be fragile. If it still works in the low column, it is more likely worth a conversation.

Fee arrangements

  • Flat fee: a set amount regardless of outcome.
  • Hourly: hours times rate. Enter the hours you were quoted in the fee box.
  • Percent of increase: a share of the amount the award adds above the carrier’s number. Some policies or circumstances raise impartiality questions about contingent fees; ask about it.

What it leaves out

Deductibles, policy limits and depreciation timing change what you are paid, not the size of the dispute. For holdback math, use the RCV / ACV holdback calculator.

Questions about this tool

Is the projected award a prediction?

No. It is a planning scenario based on the numbers you enter. Actual awards depend on documentation, the panel and the policy.

What does an umpire usually charge?

It varies with the size and complexity of the dispute. The appraisers get a quote once an umpire is proposed, and the fee is usually split evenly.

More free tools

Want a professional to check the numbers?

Send the estimate and we will review it line by line.

Call nowFree review