What appraisal clause representation means
Most Vermont homeowners and commercial policies contain a short paragraph titled Appraisal. It says that if you and the insurer fail to agree on the amount of loss, either side can demand appraisal in writing. Each side then picks a competent, impartial appraiser, the two appraisers pick an umpire, and an agreement signed by any two of the three sets the amount of loss.
Appraisal clause representation in Vermont means we are the appraiser you name. We inspect, measure and price the loss ourselves, then work the difference with the carrier’s appraiser line by line. If items stay open, we present them to the umpire with the photos, measurements and pricing that support them.
What we do on a typical file
- Read the policy and the file. Declarations, the appraisal wording, any endorsements, the carrier’s estimate and its letters.
- Inspect independently. Roof, attic, interior, mechanicals, outbuildings. We measure rather than borrow the carrier’s diagram.
- Write a line-item estimate. Priced for the property’s area of Vermont, with code items, access and overhead and profit addressed openly.
- Meet the other appraiser. Most of the movement happens here, item by item.
- Umpire, if needed. Only the items still in dispute go to the umpire.
- Award. Two signatures set the amount of loss. Payment then follows the policy’s terms, minus deductible and any prior payments.
What appraisal does not decide
Appraisal values a loss. It is not designed to decide whether the policy covers that loss, whether a delay was reasonable, or whether the carrier acted in bad faith. Those questions belong with the Vermont Department of Financial Regulation or a Vermont attorney. If your file has a coverage denial at its center, we will tell you on the first call that appraisal is probably the wrong tool.
Impartiality, in practice
Many appraisal clauses call for a “competent and impartial” or “disinterested” appraiser. We take that seriously: we disclose prior dealings with the other appraiser or the umpire, we do not work on contingency arrangements that would undercut impartiality where the policy or the circumstances make that a concern, and we price only what we can support in front of a neutral umpire.
When to call
The best time is before anyone signs a demand letter. Once appraisal is invoked, policy timelines start running, often twenty days to name an appraiser. A short review first tells you whether the gap is worth the cost and whether the file is ready.
Questions about this service
Can I invoke appraisal myself?
Usually yes. Most policies let either party demand appraisal in writing. Read your clause for the exact steps and any deadline to name your appraiser.
Is the award final?
On the amount of loss, an award signed by two of the three panel members is generally binding, subject to the policy terms and limited court review.
Who pays the umpire?
Most clauses split the umpire’s fee evenly. Each side pays its own appraiser.
