The basics
What is insurance appraisal?
A process written into most property policies for resolving disagreements over the amount of a covered loss. Each side names an appraiser, the appraisers choose an umpire, and an award signed by two of the three sets the amount.
Who can demand appraisal?
Most policies let either you or the insurer demand appraisal in writing. Some policies add conditions, so read the wording.
Is appraisal the same as arbitration?
They are related but not identical. Appraisal is usually limited to the amount of loss, while arbitration can address broader issues. Vermont courts look at the policy language.
Does appraisal decide coverage?
Generally no. If the carrier denies that the loss is covered at all, that is a coverage dispute, usually handled through a complaint to the Department of Financial Regulation or with an attorney.
Costs and timing
How much does appraisal cost?
Each side pays its own appraiser and usually half the umpire. Costs depend on the size and complexity of the claim. We quote fees in writing before starting.
How long does it take?
Many residential appraisals finish within one to three months of the demand. Larger claims and scheduling can take longer.
Is there a deadline to demand appraisal?
Some policies set a time limit, and the suit-limitation clause can also affect timing. Check your policy and talk to a professional if dates are close.
What if the gap is small?
If the difference is small, appraisal fees may eat the recovery. A documented supplement request to the carrier is often a better first step.
Vermont specifics
Who regulates insurance in Vermont?
The Vermont Department of Financial Regulation, through its Insurance Division. It licenses insurers, agents and public adjusters and handles consumer complaints.
Does Vermont have a FAIR plan or wind pool?
Vermont does not operate a coastal wind pool. Hard-to-place risks are often written by surplus lines carriers. Check with the Department of Financial Regulation for current options.
Is flood covered by a homeowners policy?
Usually not. Flood from rising water is generally excluded and covered under a separate flood policy, such as the National Flood Insurance Program.
Are ice dams covered?
Many policies cover sudden interior water damage caused by ice dams. Some limit roof repairs or ice removal. Read the water, roof and freezing wording together.
What about bad faith?
Vermont recognizes claims against insurers for bad-faith handling in some circumstances, and Title 8 lists unfair claim settlement practices. We do not give legal advice; consult a Vermont attorney.
Working with us
Are you a public adjuster?
No. We work as appraisers, estimators and umpires. A public adjuster handles the whole claim; we focus on the amount of loss.
Are you lawyers?
No. We do not give legal advice. When a claim needs a lawyer, we say so.
Do you work outside the big towns?
Yes. We work in all 14 Vermont counties, including the Northeast Kingdom and rural southern Vermont.
Can you guarantee a result?
No honest appraiser can. We can promise a thorough, defensible valuation and a candid opinion about whether appraisal makes sense.
