What the umpire does
An insurance appraisal umpire in Vermont is the third member of an appraisal panel. The two appraisers select the umpire, or, if they cannot agree, either side may ask a court to appoint one, depending on the policy wording. The umpire usually reviews only the items the appraisers could not settle, hears each appraiser’s support and signs an award with at least one of them.
How we work as umpire
- Disclosure first. Before accepting, we disclose any prior work with either appraiser, the carrier, the policyholder or counsel.
- Clear ground rules. A written outline of submissions, inspection and timing, shared with both appraisers.
- Itemized award. Where the panel wants it, an award form that separates line items, RCV and ACV, and any categories the policy treats differently.
- No side conversations. Communications go to both appraisers.
We never mix roles
On any single loss, we serve as either an appraiser for one side or the umpire, never both. If we have reviewed the estimate for either party, we will not serve as umpire on that claim.
Fees
Umpire fees are usually split equally between the parties. We quote them in writing to both appraisers before accepting the appointment.
Questions about this service
Can a court appoint the umpire?
Many policies allow either party to ask a court in the county where the property is located to select an umpire if the appraisers cannot agree.
Does the umpire inspect the property?
Often, especially on larger or more technical disputes. It depends on what the panel agrees.
Can the umpire decide coverage?
Generally no. The umpire’s role is the amount of loss on the items in dispute.
